This article reexamines the conventional 7Cs framework for effective communication (Broom & Sha, 2013). An alternative 4Cs framework is advocated. The 7Cs include: completeness, correctness, clarity, conciseness, concreteness, consideration, and courteousness. The proposed 4Cs framework retains two of the Cs in the conventional 7Cs framework (namely, concreteness and consideration) and adds two attributes (context and creativity). Concreteness subsumes completeness, correctness, clarity, and conciseness; consideration subsumes courtesy. It does not seem possible for a piece of communication to be concrete, yet lack in completeness, correctness, clarity, and conciseness. Similarly, any communication that reflects consideration is also courteous. It is further argued that of the proposed 4Cs, the context is the most critical element. It is the central theme or purpose around which the message is composed. See Figure 1. Each of the proposed four elements of effective communication is explained with examples.
Context
As stated earlier, the context of a message is the most critical element in effective communication. It serves as the nucleus or essence of the message. The other three elements in the proposed 4Cs framework namely, concreteness, consideration, and creativity ensure the message is composed to effectively convey the context to the audience.
Exhibits 1 through 3 in Appendix illustrate the importance of the right context. Three examples are given. Two versions for each of the three examples are provided. In the first (rough) version of the (example) document, the key element of context is inadequately addressed. The second version addresses the context deficiencies.
Note that the context of the document shown in Exhibit 1 is The Changes Made in the Course Outline Over at Least the Last Three Semesters. But, the text in the document has several paragraphs and sentences that do not align with the document’s context, thus making the document both irrelevant (out of context) and wordy. The irrelevant text is reproduced for easy reference and emphasis. When such text is taken out and the remaining text is restructured, the revised document becomes far more contextual and concrete than the previous version.
-
Standardization, internationalization, practical orientation, indigenization, industry-relevance, and creativity and innovation are the hallmarks of xxxx School of Management pedagogy. The process of course design, delivery, and evaluation are regularly reviewed to ensure a given course conforms to the international trends and best practices.
-
Business Communication (Course Code: xxxx) is a core course offered by the xxxx School of Management to the undergraduate programs. In Spring Semester, 2022, the ‘group course,’ was delivered to four sections by three xxx School of Management members --- Ms xxxx, Ms xxxx, and Dr xxxx. Dr xxxx was the ‘course custodian.’
-
Key topics covered included: writing to the point, writing business memos and letters, proposals, progress reports, and long reports, resume writing, job applications, effective presentation skills, conduct during meetings, and job interviews.
-
Please note that the Management Department has in place a strong monitoring and evaluation mechanism to ensure ever higher levels of course coverage and student understanding. Moreover, we rely on a strong and transparent student-feedback mechanism, that provides instructors an opportunity to work passionately towards the achievement of the all-important teaching quality metric of ‘rich and rewarding student learning experience.’
Concrete and Considerate
Concise, succinct, and terse all refer to speech or writing that uses few words to convey the message. Conciseness usually implies that unnecessary details or verbiage have been eliminated from a statement --- a concise account of the speech or a piece of writing. Concreteness is being specific, definite, and vivid rather than vague and general. A concrete communication uses specific facts and figures. See Exhibits 4 through 6 in Appendix for concreteness. In addition, to compare “Considerate” and “Inconsiderate”, please refer Exhibits 7 through 9 in Appendix.
Need for Creativity in Communication
Creativity encapsulates all conceivable dimensions of effective communication. It covers the why, when, how, and the what (content) aspects. Each one of the stated four aspects are briefly explained with examples.
Creative thinking will help you decide not only the purpose (the context) of the message, but also whether there is a need to communicate. The context aspect has already been addressed in a previous section of this article. No communication is required if there is no clear purpose. Also, it is best not to communicate in the following situations:
-
A message directed at you that has negative overtones. No reply (response) may be the best approach to embarrass the sender of the message. Moreover, it saves you from a potentially harmful situation where you get entangled in a spate of messages that is most likely to escalate the conflict.
-
A message that is sent to keep you in the loop but has no direct relevance to your job description.
-
A message that apparently asks for a ‘candid’ view on a proposed initiative, but you strongly suspect the views are sought in only one direction. Abstain (do not communicate) if your view is in the ‘opposite’ direction.
The following are some tips on when to communicate:
-
Communicate when you are comfortable you have the necessary facts and figures on hand. In case of routine email messages, respond within a day. The reply may be a complete response or a short note saying you need more time to prepare the response.
-
Other than the routine messages, avoid communicating first thing Monday mornings and last thing Friday evenings. Also, messages sent just at the close of the business day is not a good idea.
-
Also, adjust the timing of your communication somewhat if you know the recipient is in a situation (health or other reasons) where your message is likely to be ignored or not received well. Of course, this is part of consideration.
-
Wherever time permits, be among the last ones to communicate on an issue on which opinions and ideas are solicited. You will get to know the views of others and will also have more time to reflect before responding.
The how to communicate covers both the mode and style of communication. With respect to the mode of communication, the options are the written messages, speaking over the phone, a personal meeting, and non-verbal communication (body language). Written messages are the best mode for routine matters, while speaking over the phone and personal meetings are required for high-stake or conflict-prone situations.
The body language is the most vital mode of communication. The 7-38-55 rule in communication suggests that only 7% of all communication is done through verbal communication, whereas the nonverbal component of our daily communication, such as the tone of our voice and body language, make up 38% and 55% respectively.
The following are some useful tips with regard to the tone of voice and body gestures:
-
Speed+Loud+Monotone=Less listening (and low comprehension)
-
Pause as you go along; this will keep both the audience and yourself more comfortable
-
Support a proper ‘pitch;’ high-pitched (shrilly) voice distracts audience
-
Practice for the right pronunciation
-
If oral presentations are a frequent and important part of your job consider taking a course in phonetics (use of vocal sounds corresponding to pronunciation)
-
Show empathy --- an extremely important body gesture
-
Shun negative thinking; remember negative thinking will never result in positive body gestures
-
Sport a look that is a mix of warmth, empathy and sobriety
-
Sport pride in your demeanor, but do not look arrogant
-
Look firm, feel like a ragged doll; if you are relaxed, you are confident and composed
-
Your eyes will always support you if your soul is content and free from ill-will
-
Keep your eyes perceptive and deep; this might be a major body gesture in high-stake, close-encounter situations; also, this will attract people towards you
The what relates to the content. It should be both concrete and creative. A previous section in the article gives a detailed account of the attribute of concreteness for verbal communication to be effective. The content is creative when the message is composed and delivered with an ever-increasing measure of sublimity. Dig deep into your physical and emotional reserves to compose a message that has the power to reach both the conscious and the subconscious minds of your audience. The power of the message is in the novelty, depth, and practicability of the points you include. Aiming to create a subliminal message will help increase the odds for making a greater and a longer-lasting impact on your audience. Consider these tips to generate creativity in your message. This is followed by an outline for a short, ‘creative’ essay on the ways to stem the proverbial ‘rat race’ (Exhibit 10 in Appendix).
Foster your ability to be creative through:
-
Selflessness and magnanimity. Your ‘world’ and your horizon will be extremely limited if you are self-centred
-
Humility. This will liberate you from the binds of ‘resting on your laurels’ and not focusing only on the material gains. Humility will keep your zeal and hunger for the veritable pursuits alive and strong
-
Empathy. It will make you both more understanding and responsive to worry and care for others
-
Reflection. Patiently thinking and working to develop new ideas and approaches to solve issues and problems
-
Laser-like focus and concentration. “It’s not the hours you put in your work that counts, it’s the work you put in the hours” (Sam Ewing)
-
Thinking out of the box
-
Engaging in ventures or hobbies to be away from the daily routine to slow down, relax, and enjoy. You can do anything if you are relaxed
-
Shaking off the usual time bind. Undue time pressure and haste kill creativity
Conclusion
The 4Cs framework for effective communication is proposed in place of the conventional 7Cs framework. It is argued that the proposed framework is not only more parsimonious than the original framework, but it also adds a significant value to the notion of effective communication. The two new elements of context and creativity provide fresh perspective to the art and practice of communication. The article offers insights, examples, and tips to make the case for the proposed 4Cs framework. It is hoped that the new framework will be well received by both academicians and practitioners.